The kite runner movie vs book differences and analysis. To keep our thoughts organized, we use a venn diagram. Another good one is the tale of despereaux the movie is so sanitised and happified is that a word compared to the darker, and in my opinion better, book more opportunity for critical thinking. The movie started out as a man walked along the ocean to enter a huge castle. In each entry ill be comparing a contemporary novel to its film adaptation. Some people argue that watching is better than reading but such an argument. As this movie went from scene to scenefollowing the book almost to the word on some pagesmaintaining almost everythingeven the tricky flashbacks which i was 100% sure that theyd never be able to duplicate in filmeven the food served in the cafeteriai realized that this was actually the most faithful film adaptation of any book. How do you write a paper on comparing a movie with the book. Comparing the book to the movie watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. Comparing a book and a movie the book was better is a common reaction to hear among the crowd exiting a movie theater. He worked on the script for many years between other projects. Browse comparing book and movie resources on teachers pay teachers, a marketplace trusted by millions of teachers for original educational resources.
In other words, they hope the movie s success will help sell the book. This gives us a framework for our discussion, plus its a terrific visual tool. It includes questions, charts, a scaffolded compare and contrast essay template, and more. Harry potter book and movie comparison essay example. This would be the easiest, and other sources are listed below if needed. The movie also shows a significant event, caterings death, happen in the same way as it did in the book.
In preparation for this assignment, the student will have had instruction in the writing process, sentence structure, capitalization, end marks. Put in your own analysis, something only you can come create. However, in the movie, liesel actually goes as far as to tell rudy about hiding max. Compare movie versions with original books in this unit for your class. If you go into this book expecting not to cry, you are a fool. During the movie they will consider how well the movie honors the ideas presented in the book. First, you can write about each thing separately and then include a section in which you make comparisons and contrasts between them.
Was life of pi a true story of a boy stuck out in sea for 7 months with a bengal tiger, or all a lie that constantly toyed with our brains. They reach camp green lake and hide out in the hole where stanley found the lipstick tube and start digging. Check out this freebie and get questions to pose to kids. And while it may seem like i thought the movie was complete rubbish, that is really only in comparison to the original text. Outsiders book and movie comparison free essay example. This gives the audience of the movie a reason for daisy to have doubts about gatsby, but this doubt is not portrayed in the novel. Matilda comparing the book and film worksheet differentiated. Did they look the way you thought they were going to in the movie. In preparation for this assignment, the student will have had instruction in the writing process, sentence structure. This culminating activity asks students to compare and contrast the book holes and its movie adaptation. To ease my conscience and give my students the opportunity to both read the book and watch the movie, i created this fun project to test their comparing and. While some people prefer to read the book first and others want to see the movie before reading the book, there is value in comparing books and movies.
This is the first in a series of posts entitled 21st century fiction on screen. Use this book versus movie analysis project to help students gain higher order thinking skills as they compare their favourite book to the movie. Because i had asked them to take notes when we watched he movie, the students who actually listened. The film and book touches on a range of themes including loss, relationships. Book vs movie, disappointment in the difference of gone. In this lesson we compare a book to its film version and discuss several things to examine and consider when rendering the comparison and examine. The hotel scene in the movie differs from the novel for one main reason. Movie when it comes to the consumption of literature materials, different people have different tastes and preferences. These are just a few of the differences between the book and movie versions of the book thief. Compare and contrast frankenstein the book and movie.
Cite this compare and contrast the help book and movie essay. If you choose this approach, make your separate discussions of the book and movie parallel that is, for the movie, address the same points in the same order you used for the book. Compare and contrast the help book and movie essay. In the film there are several major differences between the movie and the book with three being particularly apparent. Edwin is a troubled child, his grades are terrible and he gets in fights with kids every single day. The lion, the witch, and the wardrobe the lion, the witch, and the wardrobe movie captures the main themes of c. Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. To merely list the similarities and the divergences from the plot could be done by anyone. Overall, the movie and book differences for the kite runner do not affect the poignancy of the story. Students will respond with ideas that suggest they were comparing the book to the movie and mentally noting similarities and differences. A few similarities between the movie and book are that the movie still has the complete greaser gang pony, johnny, soda, darry, dally, twobit and steve.
For those who have both read the book and seen the movie, it is pretty much consensus that the book is better than the movie. Consequently, i realized many major differences and similarities in the reading and watching of harry potter. The book and the movie, the help have more differences than similarities. Historical background is slightly more detailed in the novel, but either the book or movie make an excellent supplement to a modern history curriculum. There are many times that we read a book and our children dont even know there is a movie version. A movie and book comparison project is a comparative paper, either on two different types of genres in a book and in a movie. Kazuo ishiguros 2005 novel never let me go is both an unsettling allegory of systemic oppression, and an intimate portrait of three young people negotiating an impossible living situation. The symbolism and themes of the book are evident in the movie also. In the book, tom simply sends daisy and gatsby away. See more ideas about compare and contrast, teaching reading and reading skills. When we read jurassic park for my book club, several members preferred the more scientific, ideabased narrative. Therefore, after finishing the book, i decided to have that experience again through watching the harry potter movie, written by j. The purpose of this rubric is to allow the younger student to know what the expectations are for writing a comparingcontrasting essay. You may choose jaws, the outsiders, one flew over the cuckoos nest, something wicked this way comes, or the green mile.
Try to organize changes by section and present them in. You can also have the movie book comparison done, either of the pianist, the book and movie, or schindlers list, the book and movie. Students will compare and contrast the novel and movies plot, characters, setting, and theme. Kai lammers during our fiction unit i read the book,projectx. One of my favorite examples is when peter saves susan and lucy from the wolf in aslans camp. We would also like to view the movie and to compare and contrast the book and the movie.
Although the book is good, the movie doesnt do as much of a good job of showing the characters personalities and relationships with each other. His sister had moved there when she married dom madena, but now she was dead. Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. This free packet includes 4 graphic organizers to use when comparing and contrasting details from a. Analysis of book because the story is told from mr.
The reasoning for the director maintaining the way she died would be to highlight the overall significance of heathenish and caterings allegations, and the suffering. Pass out copies of the book and movie comparisoncontrast guide, which asks them. Apr 6, 2015 keep your students accountable for their reading by making them compare the book and the movie. After the girls and i finish reading a book and watching the movie, we spend time talking about them.
Before the students begin viewing the movie, explain to them that they will be making a double bubble thinking map comparing the book to the movie adaptation. Stanley and zero head back to camp to see what will happen to them. Pdf a comparisoncontrast essay on john greens the fault in our stars find, read and cite all. In this project, take the opposite approach, and use the book to sell the movie. This is more about content and missed bits than plot change. Another difference between high fidelity in book and movie form, as is the case with the majority of conversions between forms of text, is the amount of detail that can be included.
One prize my students have picked is to read a book, and watch the movie based on the book. But his friend flake is even more troubled, he hates everything and everyone. In a third section you would make a series of statements comparing and contrasting major aspects of them both. Encourage students to take notes during the movie screenings.
The student will compare and contrast the book the jungle book by rudyard kipling and walt disneys the jungle book. The following are noted differences between the original catching fire book and the hunger games. To ease my conscience and give my students the opportunity to both read the book and watch the movie, i created this fun project to test their comparing and contrasting skills. Compare and contrast a book and movie activities teaching. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a plotpointbyplotpoint basis. One surefire activity to get students involved in a story is comparing the book to the movie. In some cases, movies and books perform the same function particularly in cases where both the book and the movie are based on similar stories thus have related content. It will also give them the freedom to decide which version they like better. I dont feel the movie should supersede or usurp the book. The student will compare and contrast the book charlottes web to the movie of the same name. September 5 in this activity, you will explore matching textsnovels and the movies adapted from themto develop your analytical strategies. Pdf the fault in our stars the book vs the movie researchgate. This was a question that always kept readers of the book and viewers of the movie perplexed about which story was the accurate one and is what made it such a success.
Hole summary points back to camp green lake stanley and zeros friendship blossoms. November marks the release of several movies based on young adult novels, which makes it the perfect time for this kind of study. Students will select a book to read that has been made into a movie. For a no prep way to have students compare and contrast a book with its movie, check out my book vs. They should be looking for differences between the book and the movie as they watch. Reading templates and projects, grading rubrics, and free examples. The tale of despereaux novel studymovie comparison. In this literature lesson, 8th graders write an essay describing how the book and movie compared and contrasted. The tale of despereaux novel studymovie comparison my students need a class set of 30 copies of the tale of despereaux a third grade appropriate version and one copy of the dvd movie the tale of despereaux. It is virtually impossible for a twoandahalfhour film to convey the same nuances, the same tiny facets of information that are part and parcel of a novel. Both the book and the movie take you on a torturous journey into mias past to show her backstory, and then continue reading if i stay movie vs book.
As we finish, the kids can easily see how closely a movie stuck to the book. Pass out copies of the book and movie comparisoncontrast guide, which asks. Book compare and contrast guide to help them achieve a more thorough understanding of the text. My favourites for compare and contrast book to movie are the bfg and charlie and the chocolate factory. Gatsby does not grab tom and yell shut up in the novel, but does in the movie. Eighth graders compare the movie and book of where the wild things are. Wuthering heights movie and book comparison paper free. Inform students that since they have just finished the book, they are going to watch a movie based upon it. In fact, since the movie differs so wildly from the source material, it often feels like a different project, even if the overarching goals and plots are similar. The first time i saw the film adaptation of a book i had read, i was appalled at the changes that had been made to the story.
They will have a series of assignments to complete that demonstrate their understanding of both the book and the movie. Best of all, it can be used over and over again with any book that has a movie companion. Students compare and analyze novels and the movies adapted from them. Create a dvd cover that uses text and images to stress the connections between the book and movie. However, the movie and the book do not have only differences. Both gone with the wind, the movie, and gone with the wind, the book, tell an epic story of life in georgia at the time of the civil war and reconstruction era and the effect of the war on the life of a spoiled southern belle, scarlett ohara. I really enjoy these times because they read the book to read and enjoy the book, and not just to get to the movie. Select quotes from the book and images from the movie that stress their common qualities and that will. Define the subject matter, give brief, all inclusive background. With this organization, you would first write about the strengths and. By the book when a book is made into a movie, publishers often republish the book and replace its old cover art with that of the film. Hamiltons point of view, the reader receives a lot of background information about red, how he became the man he was before he died, and the qualities of a man he hopes jason will acquire. As the novels author suzanne collins was also one of the screenwriters as well as one of the films producers, it should be inferred that all changes were approved by her.
671 1419 1216 356 1593 774 947 1235 1453 411 163 485 1558 1016 909 1476 1384 711 1063 613 805 59 139 282 460 942 1386 145 1267